Talent Hub – criteria
Version 0.3.0, draft. Operator: concilio et labore GmbH.
1. Principle
We do not ask which degree you hold. We ask what you have owned, decided, overseen and resolved.
The Talent Hub admits people by responsibility actually carried in the fund sector. Years in a job count only where the person carried responsibility in them. Degrees, certificates, titles, employer prestige and career paths are never an admission criterion, never a level criterion and never a search filter. They may be listed, optionally, at the end of a profile.
Every rule in this document is applied the same way to everyone and is published on the hub’s pages, so that professionals can judge before they ask to be listed whether they qualify.
The Talent Hub is a directory. Being listed is not an application for any position. We do not match you with jobs or with companies, and we do not pass you on. The criteria decide whether a listing belongs in the directory, never whether someone suits a company’s needs.
2. Relevant areas and organisations
Areas (a professional names one main area and up to three further areas):
| Code | Area | Examples of responsibility |
|---|---|---|
| GOV | Fund governance | Conducting officer, board member of a fund or IFM, company secretary of a fund, chair of a committee |
| DEL | Delegate oversight | Due diligence and ongoing monitoring of portfolio managers, administrators, transfer agents, depositaries, distributors |
| CMP | Compliance and regulatory | Compliance function, regulatory reporting, CSSF correspondence, remediation programmes |
| RSK | Risk management | Market, liquidity, credit, counterparty, operational and sustainability risk; limits, stress tests |
| INV | Investment compliance | Pre- and post-trade limits, prospectus restrictions, breach handling |
| VAL | Valuation | Valuation policy, pricing committees, hard-to-value assets, NAV errors |
| OPS | Fund operations, NAV and transfer agency | NAV production or control, reconciliations, dealing, registers, fees |
| AML | AML/CFT and sanctions | MLRO/MLCO, KYC decisions, suspicious activity reporting, sanctions screening |
| DEP | Depositary oversight | Safekeeping, cash monitoring, oversight duties of a depositary |
| ICT | ICT risk and DORA in the fund sector | ICT risk management, information security, outsourcing and third-party oversight, incident handling |
| DAT | Data and control engineering | Data models, rule engines, controls and audit trails in production for fund or IFM processes |
| AUD | Internal and external audit | Audit of IFMs, funds or service providers, regulatory inspections |
Organisations where relevant practice can be gained: UCITS management companies, AIFMs, investment funds and their boards, depositaries, central administrations, transfer agents, portfolio managers, auditors and audit firms, law firms advising funds, supervisory authorities (CSSF or any other authority), and service providers that carry out one of the areas above for such entities. Practice outside Luxembourg counts the same as practice in Luxembourg.
Years are counted cumulatively: periods in different roles, organisations and countries add up, career breaks do not reset the count, and part-time practice counts in full where the responsibility was the same.
3. Entry filter (before any registration)
Three questions, answered by the professional about themselves, before any personal data is asked for:
| # | Question | Needed |
|---|---|---|
| Q1 | Do you have at least 3 years of practice in one of the areas above, at one of the organisations above? | Yes |
| Q2 | During that practice, did you carry responsibility yourself – for example sign-offs, oversight of a delegate, escalations, regulatory decisions or the operation of a control? | Yes |
| Q3 | Can you name at least one concrete example of such a responsibility? | Yes |
All three “yes”: the short join request form opens. Any “no”: the page explains that the directory is not yet the right place and asks for nothing else. The answers are not stored. The page says plainly that the filter is a self-assessment against published rules, and offers the contact address for anyone who believes the questions do not fit their case.
4. What counts and what does not
| Counts as responsibility | Does not count on its own |
|---|---|
| Signed off or controlled NAVs | Entered NAV data |
| Oversaw delegates, assessed exceptions, escalated | Forwarded reports |
| Took KYC decisions, handled AML cases or reports | Attended AML training |
| Ran limits, stress tests or escalations | Read risk reports |
| Owned regulatory reports or correspondence with a supervisor | Read policies |
| Built, tested or ran controls in production | Experimented with tools |
| Decided on breaches, NAV errors or compensation | Prepared figures for someone else’s decision |
| Led a remediation or an inspection response | Took part in a project without own deliverables |
Responsibility may be partial or shared (for example as deputy, or as a member of a committee), as long as the professional can describe their own part.
5. Join request (stage 1) and profile (stage 2)
Required (stage 1 short form):
| Field | Rule |
|---|---|
| Name | As the professional wants to be addressed |
| E-mail address | Confirmed by a link (double opt-in) |
| Main area | One code of section 2 |
| Years of relevant practice | Whole number, at least 3 |
| What you were responsible for | 150 to 1,500 characters |
| One decision or sign-off you made | 100 to 1,000 characters; what was decided, why, and what happened next |
| Scale | Free text up to 300 characters: funds, sub-funds, assets, delegates, team, jurisdictions |
| Availability | Open now · in 3 to 6 months · exploring |
| Declarations | Truthfulness of the information; privacy notice read; consent to the processing for the pool |
Optional (stage 1): professional profile link (e.g. LinkedIn), further areas (up to three), country where the professional is based (only to tell companies whether the professional is already in the region; no nationality).
Stage 2 profile adds, all in the professional’s own words: responsibilities per role and period (organisation type, not necessarily the name), decisions and sign-offs, problems solved, scale, delegates overseen, fund types (UCITS, Part II, SIF, RAIF, SICAR, ELTIF, MMF, other AIF), jurisdictions and supervisors, languages for work, preferred roles and working model (employed, part-time, interim, board mandate), and optionally references (names are shared only with the reviewer, and only with the referee’s knowledge) and, at the end, degrees and certificates.
Never asked: photo, date of birth or age, gender, marital or family status, nationality, religion, health, disability, trade union membership, political opinion, salary history. Free-text answers that contain such data are returned to the professional for removal before review.
6. Levels
| Level | Conditions (all of them) | Visible to companies (stage 3) |
|---|---|---|
| Admitted | Entry filter passed; required fields complete; at least 3 years of relevant practice; at least one responsibility of section 4 described; the reviewer finds the account plausible | No – internal pool only |
| Verified | Admitted; the responsibility is confirmed by two references the reviewer has spoken to or corresponded with, or by documents or public records (for example an annual report naming the professional as board member, a published mandate) | Yes |
| Oversight-ready | Verified; at least 5 years in a responsible function; documented delegate oversight or documented sign-off and decision authority (NAV, exceptions, limits, AML cases, regulatory reports) | Yes, marked |
Verified and oversight-ready are given only on the professional’s request, made in their account with a short statement of the evidence, one level after the other; the reviewer decides and records what was confirmed. A listing is shown to companies (stage 3) only when the professional has released it and it is at least verified.
The level says that the stated responsibility was checked. It is not a suitability, fit and proper or competence assessment; that remains with any company that later employs the professional (and, for key functions, with the IFM and the CSSF).
7. Refusal reasons
A refusal always names one of these reasons:
| Code | Reason | Can ask again |
|---|---|---|
| R1 | Less than 3 years of relevant practice | When 3 years are reached |
| R2 | No own responsibility described | After 12 months or with a new description |
| R3 | Practice outside the areas or organisations of the directory (section 2) | After 12 months or when the practice changes |
| R4 | Account not plausible or contradictory, and not resolved after the reviewer’s questions | After 12 months |
| R5 | No reply to the reviewer’s questions within 30 days | At any time |
| R6 | False information, impersonation or misuse | No |
| R7 | Duplicate of an existing join request or profile | – |
| R8 | The request comes from a recruitment agency, headhunter or intermediary, or on someone else’s behalf | No (as such) |
Refusal texts are respectful and short, name the reason and say when a new join request makes sense. They contain no judgement of the person.
8. Plausibility hints (help for the reviewer, never a decision)
The software may show the reviewer, from the professional’s own answers only:
- years below 3 (blocked earlier by the form, shown if changed later);
- required fields too short or missing;
- the main area not reflected in the responsibility text (keyword list per area, published with this document in stage 1);
- special-category data or contact details of third parties in free text (pattern list);
- the same e-mail address, profile link or text in another join request.
Hints are shown with their rule, can be dismissed by the reviewer with a note, and never change a status.
10. Review of these criteria
Once a year, and whenever the reviewer sees a pattern, the operator reviews: refusals by reason code, admissions by area, the time to decision, reconsiderations and their outcome, and complaints. Because the hub collects no protected characteristics, the review cannot measure effects on protected groups directly; it checks instead whether a rule excludes experienced people for reasons unrelated to responsibility (for example the 3-year threshold for people with intensive but short responsibility, or career breaks). Changes are recorded in the change log and published before they take effect.
Annex A1 – keywords per area (plausibility hint “area”)
The main area is reflected when one keyword occurs in the responsibility, decision or scale text (lower case, part of a word counts). Missing keywords are only a hint (section 8).
| Area | Keywords |
|---|---|
| GOV | conducting officer · board · director · governance · committee · company secretary · dirigeant |
| DEL | delegate · oversight · due diligence · portfolio manager · administrator · transfer agent · distributor · outsourc |
| CMP | compliance · regulator · cssf · reporting · remediation · circular · inspection |
| RSK | risk · limit · stress · liquidity · var · leverage · counterparty |
| INV | investment compliance · restriction · breach · limit · pre-trade · post-trade · prospectus |
| VAL | valuation · pricing · price · nav error · fair value · hard-to-value · model |
| OPS | nav · reconciliation · dealing · transfer agen · register · fees · subscription · redemption · settlement |
| AML | aml · kyc · money laundering · sanction · mlro · mlco · suspicious · screening · due diligence |
| DEP | depositary · custody · safekeeping · cash monitoring · oversight duties |
| ICT | ict · dora · information security · incident · cyber · outsourc · third-party · third party |
| DAT | data · control · rule engine · audit trail · automation · model · pipeline |
| AUD | audit · auditor · inspection · assurance · finding |
Annex A2 – patterns (plausibility hints “sensitive” and “contact”)
Regular expressions, case-insensitive for the sensitive kinds. A hit is only a hint; the reviewer asks the professional to remove the data (section 5).
| Hint | Kind | Pattern |
|---|---|---|
| sensitive | health | \b(health\|illness\|sick\|disabilit\w*\|disabled\|pregnan\w*\|maternity\|burn-?out)\b |
| sensitive | family | \b(married\|divorc\w*\|my (wife\|husband\|partner\|children\|kids)\|single parent)\b |
| sensitive | age | \b(\d{2} years old\|born in \d{4}\|date of birth\|my age)\b |
| sensitive | origin | \b(nationality\|citizenship\|ethnic\w*\|race)\b |
| sensitive | belief | \b(religio\w*\|church\|mosque\|synagogue\|political party\|trade union)\b |
| sensitive | orientation | \b(sexual orientation\|gay\|lesbian\|bisexual\|transgender)\b |
| contact | e-mail address | [^@\s]{1,64}@[^@\s]{1,190}\.[A-Za-z]{2,} |
| contact | phone number | (?:\+\|\b00)\d[\d ()./-]{6,}\d\|(?i:\b(?:tel\|phone\|mobile)\b)[.:]?\s*\d[\d ()./-]{6,}\d |